Why Paul Mackenzie Was Jailed for 200 Years: The Shakahola Crimes Explained

Paul Nthenge Mackenzie was sentenced to 200 years in prison because the High Court in Mombasa found him criminally responsible for the deaths of 191 people in the Shakahola killings, including 190 children and one adult. The court found that he used his religious authority to direct followers into a deadly fasting system and that violence and confinement were used against people who resisted.

The ruling followed a murder trial in which the prosecution presented survivor and other witness testimony, medical and forensic evidence, DNA analysis, digital material and evidence recovered from Shakahola Forest in Kilifi County. Mackenzie and 28 co-accused were convicted on October 19, 2026. On November 6, Justice Diana Kavedza-Mochache sentenced Mackenzie to two consecutive 100-year terms.

What did the court find Mackenzie had done?

According to the court’s findings, Mackenzie led Good News International Ministries and preached that followers should fast to death in order to meet Jesus. The court found that the fasting was organised and enforced, rather than simply a matter of individual religious choice.

The court heard that the process began with children, followed by young people, women and men. Those who resisted the instructions were beaten, restrained or confined. The judge rejected the defence argument that followers, including children, had freely chosen to starve themselves.

The court also found that Mackenzie’s teachings encouraged followers to reject education and modern medicine, isolate themselves from wider society and move to the Shakahola area. The judge concluded that his use of religious influence and the organised structure around the fasting contributed to the deaths.

How did 191 people die?

The 191 murder counts covered 190 children and one adult. In sentencing, the court separated the victims into two categories: 183 people whose deaths were attributed to starvation, including 182 children and one adult, and eight children whose deaths were classified as direct homicide.

Medical evidence in the case included findings of starvation as well as deaths involving asphyxia, neck compression and head injuries. In some cases, decomposition made it difficult for pathologists to establish a precise cause of death. The court considered the wider evidence, including witness accounts and the circumstances in which the bodies were recovered.

These 191 victims were the subject of the murder trial. They should not be confused with the much larger number of bodies recovered during the wider Shakahola investigation.

Why did Mackenzie receive 200 years?

Justice Kavedza-Mochache imposed a 100-year prison term for the 183 murder counts involving starvation and another 100-year term for the eight counts of direct homicide. The court ordered the sentences to run consecutively, meaning one follows the other, bringing Mackenzie’s total sentence to 200 years.

The prosecution had asked the court to impose the death penalty. The judge instead imposed the lengthy custodial terms, taking account of the gravity of the crimes and the circumstances set out during sentencing.

What happened to the 28 co-accused?

Twenty-eight co-accused were sentenced alongside Mackenzie after being convicted in the same case. Their prison terms ranged from 10 to 160 years, according to their respective roles and the court’s assessment of the offences. The defence has indicated that it intends to appeal the sentences.

How the Shakahola deaths came to light

The case came to national attention in April 2023, when police began investigating deaths and missing people in Shakahola Forest, near Malindi in Kilifi County. Subsequent searches uncovered mass graves and led to the recovery of hundreds of bodies from the wider area.

The Kenya National Commission on Human Rights has reported that 448 bodies were recovered in the Shakahola investigation. That wider figure includes people beyond the 191 victims covered by the murder convictions in this trial. Many families have continued to seek information about missing relatives and the identification of remains.

Other cases involving Mackenzie

The 200-year sentence relates specifically to the 191 murder convictions in the Shakahola case. Mackenzie has also faced separate proceedings over other alleged offences, including terrorism-related offences, manslaughter, child abuse and torture. Those matters are separate from the murder counts addressed in this judgment, and allegations in other proceedings should not be treated as convictions unless a court has determined them.

Why the judgment matters

The case has raised difficult questions about religious freedom, the protection of children, the exploitation of vulnerable followers and the ability of public authorities to respond to warning signs of abuse. The court’s findings show why the case was treated as murder: the prosecution established that the deaths were linked to an organised system of deadly fasting and violence, rather than an ordinary exercise of religious belief.

For families who lost loved ones, the sentence is a major legal development, but it cannot reverse the loss or answer every question about those who remain missing.

Related coverage

Read Daily Report KE’s earlier report: Shakahola: Mackenzie and 28 Others Convicted of 191 Murders — What Happens Next.

Sources

Featured image: Archival illustrative photograph of Runyenjes Law Court, Kenya, not the Mombasa court where the sentence was delivered. Photo: Kwachified / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Kelvin Kibet

Kelvin Kibet is a journalist and multimedia professional with more than six years of experience in journalism, digital media, content production, and newsroom operations.As Editor-in-Chief of Daily Report KE, Kelvin provides editorial leadership and oversees the quality, accuracy, and integrity of the platform's published content. He works with the editorial team to ensure that stories are properly reviewed, fact-checked, contextualized, and presented in accordance with professional journalistic standards.His responsibilities include supervising reporting processes, coordinating newsroom operations, reviewing stories before publication, strengthening editorial procedures, and maintaining standards of accuracy, fairness, and responsible journalism.Kelvin has experience in news reporting, digital journalism, multimedia storytelling, video production, community journalism, and editorial management. He is committed to producing informative, accurate, and public-interest content for Daily Report KE's readers.Areas of Expertise News Reporting Digital Journalism Multimedia Storytelling Investigative Reporting Community Journalism Editorial Management Video Production Content Production Key Responsibilities Editorial leadership and oversight Story review and publishing standards Fact-checking and verification Newsroom coordination Editorial planning and content development Newsroom ethics and quality control Maintaining accuracy and responsible journalism

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *